Kanpur Sibling Tragedy Sparks Outrage Over Bystander Apathy Amid Rise of 'Cameraman Culture'

A tragic road accident in Kanpur saw a brother and sister die as bystanders filmed instead of helping. Experts warned of rising "cameraman culture" and emotional apathy in India.

Rahul Sinha, Managing Editor of Zee News

A heartbreaking road accident in Kanpur has reignited a national conversation about growing public apathy and the alarming trend of filming distressing events instead of offering help. A brother and sister, severely injured after being hit by a truck, lay on the road for over 40 minutes as onlookers recorded videos instead of calling for medical assistance.

In today's DNA, Rahul Sinha, Managing Editor of Zee News, analysed the incident, which occurred around 5:15 AM near the BRS Hospital area, involved a truck ramming into a scooter carrying the two young siblings. Witness footage shows bystanders gathered around, some filming the agonizing scene while the children cried in pain. Despite several hospitals being located within close proximity, no one stepped forward to transport them to safety.

Police arrived at 5:45 AM, and an ambulance reached the spot ten minutes later. By the time the victims were admitted to the hospital at 6:10 AM, both were declared dead.

Eyewitnesses admitted that while a few tried to call for help, the majority chose to capture the incident on their phones. Authorities and social commentators have condemned the insensitivity, calling it a “collapse of collective humanity.”

#DNAWithRahulSinha : वो तड़पते रहे.. लोग वीडियो बनाते रहे, 'मैन'.. अब 'कैमरामैन' बनकर रह गया है!

#DNA #Accident #SocialMedia #UPNews | @RahulSinhaTV pic.twitter.com/fEwluyaKBh

— Zee News (@ZeeNews) May 29, 2025

Unnao Incident Mirrors The Horror

A similar tragedy unfolded just 35 kilometers away in Unnao, where a speeding tanker crushed a car carrying four people. A woman and a child died, while two others were critically injured. Once again, crowds formed—not to assist—but to film the wreckage. Viral videos from the scene show a near-carnival atmosphere as bystanders jostled to capture footage.

Psychological Insight: The “Bystander Effect”

Experts have linked this disturbing behavior to a psychological phenomenon known as the Bystander Effect, wherein individuals in a group feel less responsible for taking action, assuming someone else will. In the age of smartphones and social media, this passivity has increasingly been replaced by the urge to document rather than intervene.

Mental health professionals categorize excessive filming of tragic events as a potential sign of emotional detachment or even a disorder. With the number of smartphones increasing, what’s plummeting, experts say, is emotional intelligence and empathy.

Disturbing Statistics

India reported approximately 1.5 lakh road accident deaths in 2023. Between January and October 2024, over 1.2 lakh fatalities were recorded. Estimates suggest that 30–40% of these lives could have been saved with timely medical aid during the “Golden Hour”—the critical first 60 minutes after an injury.

Despite growing awareness campaigns, this pattern persists. A 2023 global sensitivity study ranked India 88 out of 148 nations, revealing that only 48% of Indians exhibit high emotional responsiveness. The remaining 52% show drastically lower levels of compassion and empathy.

A Call For Action

While technology has advanced and mobile cameras now record in ultra-high definition, human sensitivity appears to be eroding. Authorities, activists, and civil society groups are urging citizens to prioritize humanity over virality.

“If only one person had made the effort to take those kids to the hospital instead of filming them, they might be alive today,” said the grieving father of the Kanpur victims. “I lost my children to a camera, not a truck.”

The Message Is Clear: Be Human First

The takeaway is stark but simple: next time you witness an accident, don’t reach for your camera—reach out to help. Recording someone’s final moments may earn views, but offering help could save a life.

In an era where over 5 lakh YouTube videos, 60 lakh Instagram reels, and 40 crore Facebook clips are uploaded daily in India, it’s more critical than ever to remember: don’t just be a cameraman—be a human.