Eyeliner Guide: Types, Features & Reviews of Top Products

Eyeliner is a popular cosmetic used to define and enhance the shape of the eyes. Applied along the lash lines or waterline, it adds depth and intensity to the eyes, making them appear more expressive. Available in various forms such as pencil, liquid, gel, and pen, each type offers different finishes and application styles—from sharp, precise lines to soft, smudged looks.

istock

Eyeliners come in multiple shades, with black being the most classic and widely used. They are often waterproof and smudge-proof for long-lasting wear. Whether for a natural daily look or a dramatic winged effect, eyeliner is a versatile essential in any makeup routine.

1. MARS Ink Black Smudge Proof Liquid Eyeliner Pen

Image Source: Myntra.com

Order Now

The MARS Ink Black Liquid Eyeliner Pen is an affordable yet effective eyeliner designed for precise application and intense black payoff. It features a fine felt-tip applicator that allows you to create thin or bold lines with ease. This eyeliner is perfect for beginners and everyday wear, offering a smudge-proof finish that lasts for hours.

Key Features:

• Intense black pigment: Delivers a deep, inky finish for defined eyes.
• Smudge-proof formula: Stays in place throughout the day with minimal fading.
• Not fully waterproof: May wear off slightly with excessive sweating or moisture.
• Short wear time on oily skin: May not last all day on oily eyelids.

2. SUGAR Arrested For Overstay Waterproof Eyeliner

Image Source: Myntra.com

Order Now

SUGAR’s Arrested For Overstay Eyeliner is a long-wearing, waterproof liquid eyeliner that glides on smoothly and dries quickly. It features a flexible tip that offers control and precision, making it suitable for both bold wings and subtle lines. With its rich pigment and 12-hour stay claim, it’s ideal for long workdays or special events.

Key Features:

• Waterproof and long-lasting: Stays put for up to 12 hours.
• Quick-drying formula: Prevents smudging during and after application.
• Can dry out quickly: If not closed tightly, the tip may dry out.
• Takes practice: The liquid formula may require some skill for perfect application.

3. Stila Stay All Day Dual-Ended Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

Image Source: Myntra.com

Order Now

The Stila Stay All Day Dual-Ended Eyeliner offers two applicators in one product—one side with a fine tip and the other with a micro-tip—for ultimate control and versatility. It’s known for its high-performance waterproof formula that doesn’t smudge or fade, making it a favorite for all-day wear and professional makeup looks.

Key Features:

• Dual-ended design: Includes a regular and micro tip for detailed artistry.
• Waterproof and smudge-proof: Truly long-lasting and suitable for all-day wear.
• Premium price: On the expensive side compared to standard liners.
• Limited availability: Not as widely available in local markets.

4. KIRO Waterproof Soft-Matte Eyeliner Pen

Image Source: Myntra.com

Order Now

The KIRO Waterproof Soft-Matte Eyeliner Pen offers a clean, vegan, and cruelty-free formula without compromising performance. It features a soft-matte finish, giving a more natural yet defined look. The felt-tip applicator is beginner-friendly, and the long-wear formula makes it suitable for all-day use, even in humid conditions.

Key Features:

• Soft-matte finish: Gives a subtle, sophisticated look without high shine.
• Vegan and toxin-free: Safe for sensitive skin and eyes.
• Not ultra-black: May appear less intense than glossy black liners.
• Moderate wear time: While waterproof, it may fade slightly after several hours.

Eyeliner is a key component of eye makeup that instantly enhances and defines the eyes, adding depth, shape, and drama to any look. With a variety of types—such as liquid, pen, gel, and pencil—eyeliners offer options for every skill level and style, from subtle definition to bold winged lines. Modern eyeliners often feature waterproof and smudge-proof formulas for long-lasting wear, making them suitable for busy days or special occasions. While products like MARS and KIRO offer budget-friendly and clean beauty options, brands like SUGAR and Stila provide high-performance wear and precision.

Disclaimer: At IDPL, we help you stay up-to-date with the latest trends and products. It should not be construed as an endorsement to buy. IDPL may make a very small commission from its sale if one chooses to buy the product from any of the links in this article.